View Products |  Sign In

WOOF THE BILL Edinburgh dog walker awarded £3000

April 7, 2020

AN EDINBURGH dog walker has been forced to pay a business rival £3,000 in damages after accusing her of leaving pets locked inside a van on a hot day in a viral video.

Alana Mullen, who worked for Pilrig Paws, posted a clip on Facebook about Heather Hiram, who runs the Safe and Sound Hound dog walking service in the capital.

The video appeared to show dogs inside a van panting as temperatures outside reached 20C (68F).

Miss Mullen, 30, also claimed to have “caught and confronted” Miss Hiram, 41, and accused her of “not being able to control her dogs”.

The pair did not know each other but both walked pets in Pilrig Park.

Miss Hiram, a former solicitor, insisted her vehicle had air conditioning and cooling mats, had open windows, and demanded the ‘defamatory’ video be removed – but that request was ignored.

The clips, posted in June 2018, were shared more than 1,500 times, racked up 37,000 views and attracted scores of critical comments against Miss Hiram.

They showed Miss Mullen and a female friend confronting Miss Hiram with allegations that she left several of the dogs in her care in a hot van.

Miss Hiram launched a defamation action for £5,000 against Miss Mullen at Edinburgh Sheriff Court saying that she had been deliberately targeted and that the video led to a deterioration in her business by losing clients.

She told the court that she had spent £4,000 transforming her van and that it was the same system as used by the SSPCA and had also completed training on dog handling.

Miss Mullen argued that the statements in the video were true and could not be classed as defamatory.

But following a civil hearing, Sheriff Adrian Cottam ordered Miss Mullen to hand over £3,000 and also make a public apology to Miss Hiram.

In her apology, Miss Mullen said she had ‘jumped to certain conclusions’ when filming the video and hoped that criticism of Miss Hiram would now be ‘halted’.

She added: “I am writing this post to offer my sincere apologies to Safe and Sound Hound for the Facebook post I circulated about them which was widely shared on 26 June 2018.

“The voiceover suggested that the dogs had been in the van for around 20-30 mins on their own although the recording was less than two minutes long.

“The other videos show Heather giving dogs water and trying to explain what happened, I regret not letting Heather speak and moreover, I accept that I jumped to certain conclusions that day, which turned out to be wrong.

“When I wrote the post, I was unaware of the extent and level of Heather’s training and experience and I understand now she is as passionate about her own dogs as she is about the dogs in her care.

“I believe Heather to be a very professional dog walker and I am truly sorry for suggesting otherwise.

“All these comments were unsubstantiated and my hope is that by issuing this apology and clarifying the events of that day, people’s concerns and misunderstandings will be allayed and criticism will be halted.

“My hope is for everyone to leave the incident behind them and look forward to a positive future with, of course, the dogs’ best interests at heart.”

In a written ruling, Sheriff Cottam said: “Clearly the reputation of a dog walker would be lowered in the opinion of any right minded person reading it.

“In fact the comments posted showed the feeling of repulsion and rage against the pursuer and in effect proved even beyond doubt how the comments affected the view taken of the pursuer.

“The main issue was the risk posed to the dogs by being left in the van.

“Here I preferred the evidence of the pursuer with regard to the modifications made and the fact the adaptations took away the usual risk of dogs in hot cars.

“There was no reason to disbelieve the cost and care that went into the van and this evidence pretty much defeats the main thrust of the post that the dogs could have died.

“To post comments implying the risk of the temperature, and comments and video relating to the harm that could be caused is clearly defamatory if in fact the dogs had not been left in a situation where such risk arose.

“I am therefore satisfied that the pursuer has successfully pled her case and I find in her favour.”

Miss Hiram has been approached for comment.

 

Register Your Dog

  • Recent News

    Willow Brings Joy To Students

    June 4, 2020

    A 1-year-old black Labradoodle named Willow helped brighten the lives of St. Marys Catholic Elementary School students this year, and is still doing so for some during the coronavirus closure. Kim Sloff, inclusion coordinator at the school, is an avid animal lover. Her son was diagnosed with autism at 2 years old, and the family […]

    Read more

    RCMP Service Dog

    June 4, 2020

    RCMP say they were conducting a training session with a service dog before an officer shot an “aggressive” dog that was off-leash in the downtown area of Yellowknife. In a news release Thursday, RCMP say around 10:45 a.m. Wednesday, the police force’s Police Dog Services — which included a police service dog named Hoss and his […]

    Read more

    RCMP Investigation Update

    June 4, 2020

    Today (Thursday, June 4th) Yellowknife RCMP released an update on the investigation into the incident yesterday where a police officer discharged his firearm at an aggressive dog. The release says NT RCMP has initiated an Independent Officer Review (IOR) of the incident to determine if the RCMP’s policies and procedures were followed in the given […]

    Read more

    RCMP Police Dog

    June 4, 2020

    In a statement that amended some earlier information and contained new detail, RCMP said both an officer and a police dog were injured before any shot was fired. The RCMP account of what took place contradicted several elements of the account provided by Lawrence Mantla and Lori Dashney, who own Rocko, the pitbull shot in the […]

    Read more

    Let's Love Our Pets

    June 4, 2020

    When spring semester started, I headed home to Las Vegas for a semester-long school project for my parent’s pet harness business. Because of the business, I get to see all kinds of dogs, cats, pigs— I kid you not — goats, guinea pigs and more wearing my parent’s product. I also see the smiles on […]

    Read more

    Medical Services Dog

    June 4, 2020

    Are you a veteran or do you know someone who is a veteran and would be interested in a medical service dog? Guardian Angels Medical Service Dogs is working with the community to help pair medical service dogs with vterans experiencing PTSD, mobility issues, seizure disorders, and/or diabetes. Guardian Angels Medical Service Dogs mission is […]

    Read more

    Police Dog Service

    June 4, 2020

    An Albertan was arrested and facing several criminal charges after police from in Revelstoke, Sicamous, Salmon Arm and Vernon teamed up June 3. At around 1 p.m. Wednesday, an officer with Trans Canada East Traffic Services (TCETS), based in Revelstoke, failed to stop a vehicle for speeding on Highway 1 near Malakwa. The lone occupant […]

    Read more

    Paws Puppies

    June 4, 2020

     We could all use something to smile about right now and puppies well, they just seem to be an instant cure all. 13 On Your Side partnering once again with Paws With A cause. This time we’re sponsoring a litter of golden retriever puppies and you get to watch all their adventures as they train to […]

    Read more